Book Review
Aug. 3rd, 2006 09:30 pmIndiana
by George Sand
George Sand is one of the slightly more obscure nineteenth century authors. I think she is probably better known for being Chopin's lover than for her novels. I'd like to say that this is a pity, but unfortunately, I found Indiana disappointing. It is the story of Indiana, a young, naive woman who is married to a much older man. She falls in love with a dashing aristocrat, Raymon, but the experience turns out to be extremely painful due to his shallowness and egoism. However, the light at the end of the tunnel turns out to be the (eventually) happy resolution of Indiana's relationship with her devoted cousin and lifelong friend Ralph. My biggest disapopintment was the lack of a character I could warm to. The husband is a very callous man and very much a secondary character besides. Indiana has the seeds of strength, but utterly fails to cultivate them - she instead ends up weeping and fainting far to much for my liking. Raymon is manipulative and self-serving. Ralph is the best of the lot, but even his fortitude and goodness get tiresome. This was Sand's first novel, though, so I may give her works another chance in the future.
by George Sand
George Sand is one of the slightly more obscure nineteenth century authors. I think she is probably better known for being Chopin's lover than for her novels. I'd like to say that this is a pity, but unfortunately, I found Indiana disappointing. It is the story of Indiana, a young, naive woman who is married to a much older man. She falls in love with a dashing aristocrat, Raymon, but the experience turns out to be extremely painful due to his shallowness and egoism. However, the light at the end of the tunnel turns out to be the (eventually) happy resolution of Indiana's relationship with her devoted cousin and lifelong friend Ralph. My biggest disapopintment was the lack of a character I could warm to. The husband is a very callous man and very much a secondary character besides. Indiana has the seeds of strength, but utterly fails to cultivate them - she instead ends up weeping and fainting far to much for my liking. Raymon is manipulative and self-serving. Ralph is the best of the lot, but even his fortitude and goodness get tiresome. This was Sand's first novel, though, so I may give her works another chance in the future.