Book Review
Oct. 27th, 2026 12:48 pmThe Amityville Horror
by Jay Anson
This book claims to be the true story of a demonic haunting experienced by the Lutz family, the new owners of a house on Long Island. The malevolence of the haunting drives them to abandon the house after living in it for only 28 days. The only part of this book that is definitely true is that the adult son of the previous owners, the DeFeos, murdered his parents and four siblings one night about a year before the Lutz's bought the house. That having been said, The Amityville Horror is a pretty good haunted house story. It's reasonably scary and does a good job of incorporating several classic tropes: the rocking chair that rocks by itself, children acting creepy, cold spots, insect infestations, doors opening and slamming, and objects moving. Anson is not a great writer, sticking to straight reporting of the various incidents without generating any sense of dread or tension. Luckily, the story itself supplies that once things get going.
While I enjoyed the story, I really think that the Lutzes made it up. My theory is that there was something wrong with the house that they could not afford to fix and they needed an out that would also help with the financial hit of getting out of the mortgage and finding somewhere else to live. My guess is that it was something wrong with the heating system that was causing something to be released into the air that made everyone sick. Some of the things in the story could be based on real-life symptoms and signs of such a problem - the cold, the flies, the behavioral changes. None of the subsequent owners of the house reported having any strange experiences, and an old, failing heating system is something that a new owner with deeper pockets would likely replace before moving in.
by Jay Anson
This book claims to be the true story of a demonic haunting experienced by the Lutz family, the new owners of a house on Long Island. The malevolence of the haunting drives them to abandon the house after living in it for only 28 days. The only part of this book that is definitely true is that the adult son of the previous owners, the DeFeos, murdered his parents and four siblings one night about a year before the Lutz's bought the house. That having been said, The Amityville Horror is a pretty good haunted house story. It's reasonably scary and does a good job of incorporating several classic tropes: the rocking chair that rocks by itself, children acting creepy, cold spots, insect infestations, doors opening and slamming, and objects moving. Anson is not a great writer, sticking to straight reporting of the various incidents without generating any sense of dread or tension. Luckily, the story itself supplies that once things get going.
While I enjoyed the story, I really think that the Lutzes made it up. My theory is that there was something wrong with the house that they could not afford to fix and they needed an out that would also help with the financial hit of getting out of the mortgage and finding somewhere else to live. My guess is that it was something wrong with the heating system that was causing something to be released into the air that made everyone sick. Some of the things in the story could be based on real-life symptoms and signs of such a problem - the cold, the flies, the behavioral changes. None of the subsequent owners of the house reported having any strange experiences, and an old, failing heating system is something that a new owner with deeper pockets would likely replace before moving in.